NORBERT BARTELS
Barrister, Solicitor, Notary Public
470
Hensall Circle, Suite 304,
Mississauga, Ontario,
L5A
3V4
Tel:
905 276-8286 Fax: 905 270-0130 E.mail:
nbartels@sympatico.ca
THE CRIMINAL PROCESS:
THE START:
The criminal
process starts when someone has been charged with committing an
offence, after which the suspect is arrested by the police and
required to appear in court. The accused person will either
plead guilty or not guilty. Most people plead guilty; many
others plead not guilty and go to trial.
THE ARREST:
When a police officer makes an
arrest, the officer is required to inform the accused person why
he or she has been arrested. The person so accused has the right
to remain silent and the right to contact a
lawyer. If the police detain the person in custody, they must
charge him or her with an offence. Any person who has been
arrested must be taken before a judge or Justice of
the Peace within 24 hours or as soon as possible. Usually the
person is released on bail with various terms such as regular
reporting to the police. Those who can't make bail have to
orchestrate their defense from inside jail.
THE TRIAL:
After various administrative matters
are completed and an accused person decides to proceed to trial,
a trial date is set, usually in what is called Provincial Court.
In Ontario, it is called the Ontario Court of Justice.
If the accused person changes his or
her mind about proceeding to trial and pleads guilty instead,
there is no trial. The judge is required to ensure that the
facts justify a plea of guilty. If the judge accepts the guilty
plea, the judge holds a sentencing hearing, often immediately.
If the accused pleads "not guilty," a
trial date is set, generally months away, depending on the court's caseload. Our Charter of
Rights and Freedoms stipulates that the trial be held within a
reasonable time. A case that has taken "too long" to get to
trial may be dismissed because of the "Charter breach."
Trials are conducted on the basis of verbal
evidence, that is to say witnesses promise to tell the truth and
then give their evidence about the case. Witnesses for the
prosecution (including the police officers involved) are cross
examined by the defense counsel in the hope of extracting
evidence that will help the defense or by showing the witness's
account of events are not exactly as stated.
At his or her trial, the accused
person does not have to give evidence. No one can force an
accused person to testify. But, if the accused decides to offer
evidence, he or she may be cross-examined and must answer any
question asked, provided the question complies with the rules of
evidence.
If the charges
are proved, the judge will find the accused person guilty. If
the charges are not proved, he or she is found not guilty.
Simply put, the person is acquitted. After an acquittal, the
accused person may not be tried for that crime again, unless the
Crown Prosecutor successfully appeals the trial judge's
acquittal.
SENTENCING:
If an accused person has been convicted,
the judge must consider the appropriate sentence. Depending on
numerous factors, the presiding judge may decide to discharge
the person (absolutely or conditionally) without a criminal
record.
Or, the person may be given a criminal
record (perhaps a suspended sentence) and ordered to serve a
period of probation. People are often fined and given time to
pay the fine. If the fine is not paid, the Criminal Code sets
out a formula for the amount of jail time to be served in lieu
of paying the fine.
The offender may receive a jail sentence to
be served in the community. This is known as a conditional
sentence and is a form of house arrest with certain freedoms
such as going to work, attending school, visiting doctors or
going to probation.
Of course, the ultimate sentence is a term
served in a real jail, for the period ordered by the judge, less
time off for good behavior. Sometimes, depending on the length
of the sentence, a jail term can be served intermittently, such
as on weekends in order not to lose a job or for other good
reason.
CRIMINAL RECORD:
A person who was convicted of an offence
and is finished with the criminal justice system has more to
worry about.
Many professions will not accept members
with criminal records, however, seemingly minor. In fact, some
professions refuse applicants who do not have a criminal record
but were investigated and noted by the police as having been
involved is some way. Even those who were acquitted are seen as
tainted and undesirable.
A holder of a criminal record attempting to
enter the United States may be in for a nasty surprise,
especially if he or she has purchased an expensive
non-refundable airline ticket. Contrary to popular belief,
Canadians have no right to enter the U.S. Entries by Canadians
are at the discretion of the U.S. authorities and a criminal
record will likely result in a refusal unless the applicant has
successfully applied for a "Waiver," a time consuming process
with no guarantee of success.
CRIMINAL CODE OF CANADA (brief
overview)
The Criminal Code of Canada (CCC) contains
many subsections of what are loosely referred to as "Criminal
Law." Drug offences are not included (they are found in the
Controlled Drugs and Substances Act discussed elsewhere in this
website). Also, Motor Vehicle (Traffic) offences and Youth
crime are examined in greater detail on other pages.
The main sections of the CCC include:
FIREARMS AND OTHER OFFENSIVE WEAPONS:
Part III involves guns, knives and objects used as weapons.
Simply possessing some items is an offence (sawed off shotguns,
switch blades, etc.). There are lots of things you can do with a
firearm that will constitute an offence (no registration
certificate, careless storage, pointing it, selling it to
someone not entitled to possess a firearm and so on). Also, it's
an offence to use everyday objects as weapons, such as
hitting someone with a baseball bat or kitchen chair. Courts
deal with Part III offenses rather harshly.
OFFENCES AGAINST THE ADMINISTRATION OF
LAW AND JUSTICE: These offences include bribing public
officials, impersonating a police officer, perjury, obstructing
justice and escaping lawful custody.
SEXUAL OFFENCES, PUBLIC MORALS AND
DISORDERLY CONDUCT: Part V lists offences of a sexual
nature including sexual interference (touching someone under age
14 for a sexual purpose), invitation to sexual touching and
incest. It also outlines a number of criminally banned
activities. There are too many to list here but included are:
giving an immoral performance, mailing obscene matter,
committing an indecent act, nudity, trespassing at night and
"spreading false news."
DISORDERLY HOUSES, GAMING AND BETTING:
Here we deal with houses of ill repute ("bawdy houses") and prostitution
related offences. Also included are offences involving
gambling. Basically, you're free to gamble away every cent you
have, provided you do so in a government sanctioned activity.
Private gaming may offend Part VII.
OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON AND
REPUTATION: This part (VIII) includes assault, homicide, manslaughter, assisting
a suicide, criminal harassment, sexual assault, bigamy,
defamatory libel, advocating genocide and others. Serious stuff,
indeed.
Also included in this section are offences
involving motor vehicles (Dangerous Driving, Criminal Negligence
in the Operation of a Motor Vehicle, Impaired Driving, Driving
with Excess Blood Alcohol, Leaving the Scene of an Accident,
Driving while Disqualified). Motor vehicle offences result in a
loss of driving privileges (at least one year in Ontario,) as
well as fines or jail. For more information, click on the
Motor Vehicle page.
OFFENCES AGAINST THE RIGHTS OF PROPERTY:
This part deals with theft, fraud, robbery, extortion, break & enter,
forgery and others. What they have in common is that someone has
been victimized and left poorer as a result.
FRAUDULENT TRANSACTIONS RELATING TO
CONTRACTS AND TRADE: Part X contains offences involving
elements of fraud in one form or another.
CURRENCY OFFENCES: Counterfeit
money, slugs and the like are included.
PROCEEDS OF CRIME: This sets out
how government can deal with money or goods deemed to be
"proceeds of crime." It shows what the government has to prove
in court in order to keep the stuff and how one can get it back
if it isn't "proceeds of crime."
ATTEMPTS, CONSPIRACIES, ACCESSORIES:
Part XIII deals with persons who attempt (but don't succeed) to
commit offences as well as persons who get together to plan and
carry out offences and persons who help others commit offences.
Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure are
fairly complex and should best be handled by an experienced
criminal lawyer. People finding themselves facing a criminal
charge should take it very seriously and not try to defend
themselves. It's not an area to dabble in or learn as you go.